Cornell University Athletics

May was an NFCA (National Fastpitch Coaches Association) third team All-America selection as a senior. A two-time Ivy League Player of the Year (2004, 2005), she was also named the 2002 Ivy League Rookie of the Year. She earned Ivy League accolades all four years she played for the Big Red, including first team honors three times. May was the 2005 ECAC Player of the Year and a three-time Louisville Slugger/NFCA Division I All-Region First Team selection. She set nine single-season and career school records, including a season slugging percentage of .930, which ranked first among NCAA Division I players in 2004. She also graduated with six Ivy League marks, including four which she still holds. May had top marks for games played (55 season), hits (69 season, 226 career), home runs (16 season, 58 career), RBI (56 season, 190 career), batting average (.496 season, .415 career), total bases (132 season, 443 career), career slugging percentage (.814), career walks (79), on-base percentage (.578 season, .483 career) and assists (130 season, 384 career) in Cornell history.