A consensus third-team FCS All-American (Associated Press, Phil Steele, College Sports Madness) and a first-team All-Ivy League receiver in 2011, Savage led the Ivy League in receptions (65), receiving yards (1080) and receiving touchdowns (12). He finished fifth nationally in yards per game and 13th in receptions per game while setting school records for season yards and touchdowns. Savage averaged 123 yards per game in league games (860 yards) with nine touchdowns in seven contests. His 12 touchdowns ranked sixth all-time in a season in Ivy history, and his three touchdowns against both Columbia and Penn tied a school record. A first-team Capital One Academic All-District selection, he posted four 100-yard games in 2011 and had four contests with multiple touchdowns. He missed his senior season due to injury.