Kusseluk was a third-team All-America selection and two-time first-team All-Ivy selection during his career. He led the Big Red in scoring his junior and senior seasons and ended his career in second place in career points (72) and tied for second in goals scored (32) in school history. Kusseluk also remains tied for second in season goals scored (18) and in third place for season points (37). He received the 1996 men's Outstanding Senior Varsity Athlete Award, given to the senior student-athlete whose level of play distinguished him within the team, Ivy League and nation. Kusseluk led the Big Red to two NCAA appearances, in 1995 against Lafayette and 1996 against Rutgers. He was also part of the 1995 squad that co-shared the Ivy title with Brown.
