Keith was named an honorable mention All-American following his senior season. He was a two-time All-Ivy selection, earning second-team accolades in 2013, after an honorable mention selection in 2012. One of the most underrated players in the nation; he finished his senior season ranked 20th in the country in caused turnovers (1.83 per game) and 43rd overall in ground balls (4.67 per game). He finished his career with 188 ground balls and 68 caused turnovers.Â