As a senior, Tucker finished the season 32-0 and was named a finalist for the prestigious Dan Hodge Trophy, awarded to the nation's most outstanding wrestler. Tucker went 9-0 against ranked opponents as a senior and was set to enter the 2020 NCAA Championships as the #3 seed. Following the cancellation of the NCAA Championships, Tucker was awarded first-team All-American honors by the National Wrestling Coaches Association. Tucker concluded his Big Red career with an overall record of 82-18. The native of Worcester, Mass. earned two Eastern Intercollegiate Wrestling Association (EIWA) titles at 133 pounds and was named first-team All-Ivy three times, having never lost during an Ivy League dual (15-0).