Greenway, a first-team All-Ivy selection and a finalist for the Fred Mitchell Award, was named to the Beyond Sports Network honorable mention All-America team in 2011. Greenway led the Ancient Eight in scoring (7.5 points per game), ranking 41st nationally. He set the Cornell kick scoring record for a career (189 points) and season (75 points), while his 189 career points ranks third all-time in Big Red history. Greenway finished 18th nationally in field goals (13, 1.3 per game), a mark that was second in the Ancient Eight. He was the only kicker in the Ivy League to post a perfect season on extra-point kicks (36-of-36) and was 5-of-5 on field goals of 40 yards or more. The two-time Special Teams Player of the Week also kicked off and punted for Cornell and was the team's captain on special teams.