Noble was a three time All-America selection, being chosen to the first-team in 2013 after a second-team selection in 2012 and an honorable mention nod in 2011. Noble was also a two-time first-team All-Ivy selection, after earning honorable mention accolades his sophomore season. As a senior, he was the anchor of the 15th best defense in the nation, allowing opponents just 9.06 goals per game, and he ranked 16th in the nation in caused turnovers (1.8 per game). The Big Red's most consistent ground ball guy, Noble registered at least one ground ball in all but one game during his career and left Cornell ranking 10th overall with 216 career ground balls. After holding the reigning Tewaaraton Trophy winner, Colgate’s Peter Baum, to just one meaningless assist and only three shots, none of which were one goal, Noble was named the Ivy League Co-Player of the Week on March 4, 2013, becoming the first defensemen to win the award since the 2010 campaign. That same week, he was honored as the National Player of the Week by the Baltimore Sun.