Haber was named to the NSCAA All-America first team as a junior after leading the team with 18 goals and 43 points, including leading the country in goals per game (1.06) and points per game (2.53) in 2012. His scoring prowess – including five game-winning goals – helped the Big Red to its first Ivy League title since 1995 and its first NCAA Tournament berth since 1996. He was named a semifinalist for the MAC Hermann Trophy after scoring 43 points, good for second-best in school history, behind only Victor Huerta's 47-point year in 1972.Haber was named to the All-Ivy first team and was the first men's soccer player ever at Cornell to win the Ivy League Player of the Year award after helping the team to a 15-2 finish. He also won the Ivy League's Player of the Week award a record five times during the season. Haber turned pro in 2013, signing a contract with Maccabi Haifa FC, one of the elite teams in Israel’s Premier League.