A two-time All-American who finished sixth at the NCAA championships in both 2008 and 2011, Grey helped the team to second-place finishes in 2010 and 2011 at nationals, the highest finishes in program history. He finished an impressive collegiate career with a 117-30 record and ranked third on the Big Red leader board for most major decisions. A four-time NCAA qualifier, he was named the 2008 Ivy League Rookie of the Year and the 2008 Rev Wrestling Freshman of the Year. Grey was also a four-time All-Ivy first team selection, as well as a two-time EIWA champion. He was honored with the Andy Noel Leadership Award during his junior campaign and in his senior season he served as the team captain. Following his senior year, Grey was honored with the Eric LaFrance “Tough Guy” Award for the wrestler showing impressive strength through adversity.