Georgalas was named first-team All-Ivy and honorable mention All-America in 2005 after helping Cornell to 11-3 overall record, completing its first perfect 6-0 Ivy League season and its first outright Ivy title since 1987. He headed up the Big Red defense and served as a team captain during his final two seasons. During his senior campaign, Cornell held its opponents to fewer than eight goals per game, largely due to the fact the Georgalas held opposing attackers in check throughout the year. The team's most respected leader, Georgalas collected 37 ground balls as a senior, and helped the Big Re to advance to the NCAA quarterfinals for the second straight season where they fell to national runner-up Duke, 11-8. He was selected to compete for the North team in the 64th annual North-South Classic. Following graduation, Georgalas and was drafted by the New Jersey Pride in the fifth round of the 2005 Major League Lacrosse collegiate draft.
