A four-time first-team all-league selection in ECAC Hockey and the Ivy League, Jenner earned first-team All-America honors in 2013 and second-team accolades in 2015. The two-time ECAC Hockey and Ivy League Player of the Year, Jenner graduated as the program's all-time assist leader with 136 career helpers and second all-time with 229 career points. A four-time Patty Kazmaier Award nominee, she was twice a top 10 finalist. She earned a spot on ECAC Hockey Tournament's all-tournament team and captured Ivy League Rookie of the Year trophy as a freshman in 2011. Jenner sat out the 2013-14 school year while competing for Team Canada at the 2014 Sochi Olympics, helping the squad to a gold medal.